Human Experimentation Is Only Moral With Informed Consent

Introduction The argument I will be making in this essay is that human experimentation is only moral with informed consent. I believe that it is essential to gain informed consent before starting experimentation as to prevent any uninformed and unnecessary harm coming to the subject. In arguing for informed consent, will do three things; first I will explain what informed consent means. Second, I will consider an argument that sometimes informed consent is not required as it is sometimes difficult to acquire and offer my objection to it. Third, and finally, I will offer my own argument that human experimentation with informed consent is always necessary. Informed Consent For the definition of informed consent, I will be using the†¦show more content†¦I believe that a person who is persuaded into an experiment is at an increased risk for being susceptible to harm. This issue has come up in history, such as in Word War II with the Nazis which resulted in particular guidelines to follow for experiments, knows as the Nuremberg Codes. Examples of these guidelines includes: â€Å"The voluntary consent of the human subject†¦the experiment should be conducted as to avoid all unnecessary physical and mental suffering and injury†¦during the course of the experiment, the human subject should be at liberty to bring the experiment to an end†¦Ã¢â‚¬  (The Nuremberg Trials). The requirements of informed consent are similar to these guidelines, and therefore should be considered necessary to all experiments in which human subjects are involved. When Informed Consent is Difficult to Obtain One argument against the requirement for informed consent is that at times, it can be difficult or impossible to obtain. An example of a case where informed consent might be difficult to obtain is in experiments where it is crucial for the subjects to not know they’re being experimented on. One case similar to this is the Milgram experiment. The Milgram was an experiment conducted in the 1960’s in which theyShow MoreRelatedThe Ethical Ethics Of The Tuskegee Syphilis Study1154 Words   |  5 PagesOver the years human experiments has developed the knowledge of human physiology and psychology. However, the use of human’s subject in research have to become a controversial issue in our society. It has become a debatable questions whether it’s ethical or not. There has to be a limit to where certain experiments can be implemented on humans such as trials for drugs and social experiments. There are moral principles t hat guides our research into deciding what is â€Å"right or wrong†. This principlesRead MoreEthical Implications Of The Clara Case835 Words   |  4 Pagesimplications of making a moral judgment on past actions by researchers regarding human experimentation are discussed. The central ethical conflicts of the Clara’s case are several infringements committed regarding human rights in human experimentation. According to the American Psychological Association Code of Ethics [APA] (2010) experiments such as Clara would have violated several sections from standard 8: 8.01 (obtaining institutional approval), 8.02 (participants’ informed consent), 8.04 (client/patientRead MoreThe Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks Essay1258 Words   |  6 Pagesour society, are the moral principles that govern our behavior, dictating what is right from wrong. The specifics of ethics changes as values in our society change and evolve. This occurs in Rebecca Skloots book, The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks. One major reoccurring theme in the book is the lack of informed consent and autonomy. Fortunately, now there are safeguards which protect human rights in regard to health care and research. The Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of BiomedicalRead MoreThe Invention Of The Polio Vaccine920 Words   |  4 Pageshealed, or touched by the cells of a woman whose name we never knew. Her name was Henrietta Lacks. She was an African-American woman who died of an aggressive form of cervical cancer at Johns Hopkins in 1951. Her cells were taken without her consent nor the consent of her family members after her death and used for research from the effects of cosmetics to the formation of the polio vaccine. The cells, tagged as â€Å"HeLa† by the scientist who received them at Johns Hopkins where Henrietta had come for treatmentRead MoreIslamic and Catholic Views on Genetic Engineering1265 Words   |  6 Pagesunnecessary and unethical. It is an embellishment to human vanity and additionally, insults human integrity when the offspring is affected by the technology. (What is the Catholic view on genetic engineering? - Mary Meets Dolly. 12/ 05/ 2014.) The Catholic Church In 1983, Pope John Paul II mentioned in an address â€Å"genetic enhancement was permissible- indeed, laudable- even from a Catholic point of view, as long as it met certain basic moral rules. Among those rules: that these therapies be availableRead MoreEssay on Human Guinea Pigs: Prisoners2045 Words   |  9 Pagesof the social pyramid was always those seen as lacking morals. Whether immoral qualities were synonymous with skin color or occupation, a supposed lack of moral integrity allowed for those higher in stature to impose at times grueling oppression upon the degraded. As society evolved many advances pushed for equality among the masses so that each man or woman was allowed the freedom of bias or judgment. However, no matter how advanced the human race, there is still a hierarchy and at the lowest ofRead More Medical Research and Dependent People Essay3346 Words   |  14 Pages How may children and other dependent individuals are subjects in research projects to which they cannot consent and from which they cannot benefit? This topic was much discussed in the United States about twenty-five years ago, but has recently reemerged in the discussion of the European Convention on bioethics and through current discussion in the medical literature of the kinds of consent and experiments appropriate in the Third World. I summarize the U.S. discussion and solution, present theRead MoreWho Owns Your Cells? Essay1648 Words   |  7 Pagesuntil Rebecca Skloot uncovered it.1 Information about Henrietta Lacks uncovers a history of consent not being asked for, and certainly not being given, but because of the cells, medical discoveries were made without her family’s knowledge.1 It brings to light the idea that while cells are a part of a person’s body, once they are out of the human body there is no more ownership. Without informed consent though, is it still owned by the person whose cells they are? In the end, for Henrietta LacksRead MoreHuman Experimentation1684 Words   |  7 PagesTOPIC #4: Human Experimentation PRO: Prisoners should be allowed to participate in human research CON: Prisoners should not be allowed to participate in human research History and definitions Dating back to 1965, seventy-five prisoners at Holmesburg prison in Pennsylvania were purposely exposed to a poisonous agent. This study was conducted to determine the effects of dioxin, a potentially harmful substance. Dermatologist Dr. Albert Kligman, exposed prisoners to a dosage 468 times greaterRead More10 Principles Regaarding Ethical Clinic and Set of Guidelines on Clinical Research1071 Words   |  5 PagesNuremberg Code is a set of 10 sophisticate principles regarding ethical clinical research on human being (Grodin, 1994). It is mainly for protection of subjects’ human right (Shuster, 1997), such as compulsory of informed consent and the equal authority of subjects as the physician-researcher to end the experiment. 1.2 Helsinki Declaration (1964) Helsinki Declaration is a set of guidelines on clinical research for physician as their responsibility toward protection of their research subjects